
The best carry on is the one that suits your trip length. That sounds obvious, but I've watched plenty of people (me included) buy a bag because it looked nice in a photo, then fight with it at the gate a month later.
One was great. One was fine. Two were mistakes I kept for way too long because I didn't want to admit I'd wasted the money. This guide is what I wish someone had told me before that first purchase. It's not about finding one perfect bag for everyone. It's about finding the right one for how you travel.
Short on time? Our top picks: Away, Samsonite, Travelpro and Briggs & Riley. See all picks

You don't need much to do this well. Gather these before you start shopping:
That's it. No fancy tools. The notebook part matters more than you'd think, because once you start comparing bags, the details blur together fast.
Start here. Before you look at a single bag, go to the website of each airline you fly and find their carry-on size limit. Write down the height, width and depth for each one.
Here's the annoying part. Airlines don't all use the same limits, and they can change them. Budget carriers are often stricter than the big ones. Some count wheels and handles in the measurement, and some flights on smaller planes have tighter rules than the airline's usual policy.
Once you have your list, use the smallest set of numbers as your target. If one airline allows a slightly bigger bag but another doesn't, the smaller limit wins. Otherwise you'll end up checking your bag on the one flight where you really didn't want to.
When you look at bags, find the listed dimensions on the seller's page. Make sure they include wheels and handles. Some listings quietly measure only the main body, which can make a bag seem smaller than it is.
Tip: If a bag is right at the limit, think twice. A bag that's packed full can bulge past its listed size, especially soft-sided ones. A little wiggle room saves stress at the gate.
This one gets skipped a lot, and it shouldn't. Every carry-on has an empty weight, and it's usually listed on the product page. If it isn't listed, I'd be a little suspicious.
Why does it matter? Some airlines have a weight limit for carry-ons, not just a size limit. If your bag is heavy before you've packed a single sock, you have less room for actual stuff. And even if your airline doesn't weigh bags, you still have to lift it into the overhead bin. Over your head. While someone waits behind you.
Lighter isn't always better, though. Some very light bags feel flimsy, with thin fabric or wobbly frames. You're looking for a balance: light enough to lift easily, solid enough to survive being shoved under a seat.
If you already own a bag, weigh it empty on your scale. Then you'll know whether the new one is actually lighter or just sounds lighter in the description.
Tip: Pick up your fully packed current bag and lift it to shoulder height a few times. If that feels hard, weight should be high on your list.
You've got two main choices: two wheels or four. And then there's the option of no wheels at all, which some people love.
Two-wheel bags roll behind you. They tend to handle curbs, cobblestones and rough sidewalks better because the wheels are usually tucked into the bag's frame. They also give you a tiny bit more packing space inside.
Four-wheel bags (often called spinners) glide next to you and turn easily. They're lovely in a smooth airport. On a bumpy street, not so much. The wheels stick out more, which can mean they're easier to damage and take up some of your size allowance.
My honest take? If most of your trips involve walking on old streets or uneven paths, I'd go with two wheels. If you mostly go from car to airport to hotel lobby, spinners are really nice.
If you can see the bag in a store, roll it around. Push it, pull it, turn it. Listen for rattling. If you're buying online, read reviews that mention wheels specifically, and pay attention to complaints that come up more than once.
Tip: Look at how the wheels attach. Wheels that are bolted or screwed on can sometimes be replaced. Ones that are sealed in may mean the whole bag is done if a wheel breaks. Check the seller's page or ask them if it's not clear.
Handles seem boring until one breaks in the middle of a train station. Ask me how I know.
The telescoping handle (the one that pulls out of the top) should extend smoothly and lock firmly at each height. If you're tall, check that it goes high enough so you're not hunching over. If you're shorter, make sure there's a lower setting that feels comfortable.
Shake it a bit when it's extended. A little movement is normal. A lot of wobble usually gets worse over time, not better.
Don't forget the carry handles too. Most bags have one on top and one on the side. These are what you grab when you're lifting the bag into a bin or up stairs. They should feel padded or at least solid, not like a thin strap that'll dig into your fingers.
Tip: If you're shopping online, look for photos of the handle fully extended. Bags that only show the handle tucked away sometimes have a reason for hiding it, which matters most for a rolling carry on.

This is where people's preferences really split. Some want one big open space. Others want every pocket and divider possible.
Hard-shell bags usually open like a clamshell, with two halves. That's great for keeping things separate, but you need floor space to open them all the way. In a tiny hotel room or a cramped train cabin, that can be a real pain.
Soft-sided bags often open from the top like a lid, and many have outside pockets. An outside pocket is great for a jacket, a book or a liquids bag, so you can grab them at security without unzipping everything.
Look for things like:
Here's something I think is overrated: built-in laptop sleeves inside wheeled carry-ons. Your laptop usually needs to come out at security anyway, and digging for it inside a rolling bag is clumsy. You can keep yours in your personal item instead. Your mileage may vary.
Tip: Picture how you actually pack. If you use packing cubes, a big open space works best. If you just toss things in, more pockets will help keep you sane.
By the way, if you're getting ready for a trip soon, the free Vacation Countdown Checklist and 1-Day Itinerary Page is yours when you join our email list, and it pairs well with a new bag.
Now pull out your notes from the start. How long are your usual trips?
For a weekend away, almost any carry-on that fits the airline limits will do. You could even skip wheels and go with a soft duffel or a carry on luggage backpack, such as one from Osprey. For trips of five days to a week, the layout and space from Step 5 start to matter a lot more. For longer trips, you'll probably be doing laundry along the way, so you don't need a giant bag. You need an efficient one.
Think about the season too. Winter clothes take up a lot more room than summer ones. If you mostly travel in colder months, lean toward a bag with a bit more usable space.
If you're comparing a few bags side by side, the Carry-On Luggage Buyer's Guide and Comparison Sheets below this post give you a place to write down the size, weight and features of each one. They exist because a general notes app can easily turn into a mess.
Tip: Do a pretend pack. Lay out what you'd bring for a typical trip on your bed. Then compare that pile to your current bag's space. It'll tell you whether you need more room or less.
Don't skip this. Even after all the research, a bag can feel different in person. The color might be off. The wheels might be noisier than you expected. It might just not feel right.
Before you buy, check the seller's return policy. Look for how many days you have, whether you pay for return shipping, and whether the bag needs to be unused. Some sellers won't take a bag back once the tags are off.
Also look at the warranty, if there is one. Read what it actually covers. Some cover only manufacturing defects, not damage from airline handling. The seller's page should spell this out. If it doesn't, ask them directly before you pay.
Tip: When the bag arrives, test it at home first. Pack it, roll it around the house, lift it onto a high shelf. Keep the tags on until you're sure.
This usually happens when a soft bag is packed too full and bulges. Next time, skip the expansion zipper and pack a little lighter. You can also double-check that the listed size included the wheels and handle.
Clean out any hair or grit wrapped around them. That fixes it more often than you'd expect. If they're still bad within the return window, send it back. That's what the window is for.
Go back to your trip length and your usual streets. Those two things settle most ties. If they're still even, choose the lighter one. Your shoulders will thank you.
Before buying something bigger, try packing cubes or rolling your clothes. Often the problem is packing style, not bag size. A packing list helps too, because most of us bring things we never touch.
These are well-known carry-on brands that cover different budgets and travel styles. Use your notes from the steps above to decide which one fits.
Suits travelers who like a clean, simple look and mostly buy online. Check the current return and warranty terms on the seller's page before ordering.
A long-standing brand with many carry-on styles, both hard and soft sided. Look closely at the listed dimensions, since sizes vary a lot between models.
Often a fit for frequent flyers who want a rolling bag built for regular use. Compare the empty weight across models, as it differs by line.
Worth a look if you want a bag you plan to keep for years. Read the warranty details carefully so you know what is and isn't covered.
A good option for people who like hard-shell bags and a wide choice of colors. Check the wheel type and how they attach before choosing.
Suits short trips and anyone leaning toward a carry-on backpack instead of a rolling bag. Check that the pack meets your airline's carry-on size, not just the personal item size.
Makes travel backpacks aimed at people who want to skip wheels. Try the harness and back padding for comfort, especially if you walk a lot.
Check current plans and prices on each brand's own site.
Neither is better for everyone. Hard-shell bags protect fragile things a bit more and look neat, while soft-sided bags usually have outside pockets and a little give. Think about what you pack and where you open your bag.
If it's ever been questioned at the gate, yes. Measuring it shows you what size actually works for you. It also gives you a real comparison when reading listings online.
That depends on your budget and how often you travel. Someone flying once a year has different needs than someone flying every month. For the best affordable carry on luggage, I'd focus on wheels, handle and return terms over brand names.
Plenty of people do, especially for short trips, with packs from brands like Tortuga. Just check that it fits your airline's carry-on size, not only the personal item size. Comfort matters too, so look at the straps and back padding.
Start with your airline's size limits today, even if you're not buying yet. It takes five minutes and saves a lot of guessing later. Then grab the free Vacation Countdown Checklist and 1-Day Itinerary Page by joining the email list, so your next trip feels a little calmer. When you're ready to compare bags or plan your packing, take a look at the Carry-On Luggage Buyer's Guide and Comparison Sheets and the Trip Planner and Packing Checklist Bundle below this post. Happy packing.
A printable guide and comparison sheets to write down what matters to you before you look at any seller...
See detailsA printable bundle with a 30-day goal page, weekly planner and checklists for frequent travelers and...
See details